tribs wrote:
Just opened a Hospitalier 07.
It seems to have a rather bitter finish. Checked the bottle and there seems to have been some wine seepage from the cork. Possibly tainted.
Will await your TN Duncan.
Possibly tainted It may seem as such, yet it could be the wine at this stage. I'm affraid you will need to open another to be sure. In the meantime, I would return that bottle, with £1.50 in your pocket, and exchange for the '07 Saint Joe that is on offer and liked by Jancis and which I find to be ready and very nice for the disco price.
Yes ~ ~ ~ I've been making up my mind about this Cairanne. I have already consumed three of these. The one enjoyed with rich food on Saturday did an excellent job. A very rich wine on entry, richer than many chateau neuf, but the lift one hopes for from the Grenache fruit is swamped with unharmonious oak.
There is a bitter finish at the mo, produced by the unintergrated oak, it is over savoury just now. I dont think the wine is ready, whilst the concentrated Syrah is dark and brooding and spicy, it does not provide pleasure at the moment. Because the oak is too much, I can't tell if acidity is enough to be right, yet 5 day old dregs were still a nice middle flavour.
I'm keeping the two remaining bottles for next year. I don't think the fruit in this wine will dry out from cellaring, it is quite firm, I think this wine has a much brighter future.
If however, you are wanting a wine with a beef stew or rich liver and bacon casserole right now, this could be the one. Not ready, and not recommended for drinking now, except by me
especially not so, for folks who don't normally enjoy rustic Rhone wines.
Tribs this is a general comment, rather than a proper TN. The producer's drinking notes on the back label are not replicated in the mouth - yet ? If they were there before, the wine is going through a sleeping stage, and I need to wait again.
Are there any cellar notes for say the '03, drunk 6 years later ? Those notes would provide more certainty
I'm fairly sure it will come good, and might come very good for the price. It is an amazingly structured wine for the price.