meljones wrote:
Do you mean we, as a forum, have been having a (-ve) go at Jadot, or you as a family, have been having a (+ve) go at Jadot. I rate their Bourgogne Chardonnay, but am interested to hear that the Macon is good. I haven't seen a Budgens for years.
We on the forum and me and my two burgundy loving friends.
Mel......You said this recently:
We had three Louis Jadot wines and the panel liked the cheapest, a Mâcon, most. Louis Jadot, Mâcon, Les Roches Rouges 2008 is £9.99 in Majestic or £7.49 if you buy two. It had quite a sweet smell – like very ripe cherries and with a hint of popcorn. It’s a young and fruity number – great for the summer –
but the feel is linear, bordering on the simple. I gave it rather low marks, but the panel seemed to love it.
Louis Jadot’s Côte de Beaune Villages 2007, which is £10.99 in Sainsbury’s and £11.49 in Waitrose, had a pretty typical aroma. It was fragrant, with some cherry, but a little earthy as well. During the evening it picked up some curry spice. The taste was fine, but disappointing if you were hoping that spending eleven quid on 2007 Burgundy was going to give you something fascinating.
It’s perfectly fine for a summer lunch and it’s nice, but it hasn’t even started to get interesting.
You’d need to be loaded and buy quite a lot and then try it at three monthly intervals until it started to get interesting, and then go for it.
There seems little point when Les Mouchottes and Réserve de la Basion are cheaper and, well, just better.
The real disappointment of the evening was the Jadot Gevrey Chambertin 2007, which is around £27.59 at Dickens House, Eagle Wines, Hailsham Cellars, Peckams and Taurus Wines. The smell was very definitely Pinot. Just as expected – young, but ripe, strawberry. However the mouth feel was very gentle, which isn’t exactly what I was expecting from a Gevrey, and it was dry and short. Once we’d uncovered them I went back to it and tried to find some depth, some beauty, but it was simple and short.
The
pop me and my friends have been taking is for:
1)Bourgogne rouge '06 and '07 which was over dry and dull, no cherry fruit, and deserved to be punished ,
2) A rubbish Beaujolais villages 2008 with no gamay fruit or fragrance - dried out as well - the 07 was pretty dull, and a waste of money. Combe aux Jacques '08 ..lacked vital spark. Dry and a bit tart without enough fruit in the middle.
3) A Beaune rouge 1er on '06, a generic mix, not at all satisfying, thin, short, boring, no fragrance - whereas - Chanson Bastion 1er, although a quid or so more, was most engaging and a lot more concentrated- and showed up the LJ as if it was an ordinary Hautes-côtes de Beaune from a supermarket.
4) 18 months ago - A gum numbing Morgon on the '04 was dire. I think we tipped it down the sink.
At the sub £12 mark, LJ's Bourgogne blancs have been better in recent years. I'm very pleased with his Macon Villages '09.